Taking too long? Close loading screen.
find a lawyer


(777) 777-7777

— Click to Call —

What Is An Independent Medical Evaluation?

November 17th

What Is An Independent Medical Evaluation?

In a Utah workers comp claim, a doctor’s opinion can be even more important than a judge’s. Doctors hold the key to opening or slamming shut the door on your claim, and insurance companies know this.

When you’re hurt at work, your insurer will try to do two things to save a little money. First, they’ll try to send you to a doctor in the insurer’s own network, with whom they already have a negotiated rate.

Second, they’ll send you for an Independent Medical Evaluation/Examination—otherwise known as an IME. The truly accurate name IME stands for should be an Insurance Medical Exam.

Although the word “independent” is right there in the name, many IMEs are far from independent. Read on to find out why.

Not-So-Independent Evaluations

Insurance companies are well aware of the role your doctor’s opinion plays in the success or failure of your workers compensation claim, and claims adjusters commonly select doctors who have a track record of helping them close cases as quickly as possible.

These IME doctors are usually NOT neutral, independent, objective, or any of the other traits you’d expect from a doctor. Instead, they act as paid witnesses to the insurance company, acting on their behalf—not yours.

Whatever you say to this IME doctor can and will be used against you to minimize the extent of your injuries, all in order to back up the insurance company’s decision to stop paying your claim.

Even worse, some insurance companies have even been known to hire private investigators to monitor you on your way to the doctor and back, sometimes even filming you in the process. Remember, the insurance company is NOT your friend—they’ll try to save money by any means necessary.

Rebutting an IME Designed to Sink Your Case

There are two great ways to strengthen your case against a biased IME report:

1. Choose your own treating doctor. In Utah, you have the opportunity to choose your own medical provider. You may be required to visit the insurance company’s treating doctor a first time, but you are allowed to make a change of physician–once–without the insurance company’s permission or a referral from their doctor. After you change physicians once, you may only change doctors again if your treating doctor refers you to someone else or to a specialist.

2. Get a true independent evaluation by your own trusted physician. Sometimes, showing your treating doctor the conclusions of the IME doctor will make him so angry that he’ll gladly write a rebuttal or contrary opinion in your behalf.

Don’t let your insurance company bully you into making the wrong decision—if you’ve been asked to undergo an IME, or recently went through one already, give us a call right away. We’ll help you figure out if you’ve been taken advantage of by your insurer, and work with you to figure out the next step.


Zero out-of-pocket costs, crystal-clear communication, immediate action on your case. With hundreds of clients served and years of combined experience, the attorneys of Davis Sanchez are known for their dedication to winning maximum settlements and judgments for their clients.

*The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice; instead, all information, content, and materials available on this site are for general informational purposes only.

Do you have a case?

The longer you wait, the lower the chance you have of getting compensation. Contact us NOW for a free case evaluation.

Free Consultation

Davis & Sanchez

This law firm is owned by nonlawyers. Some of the people who own and manage this entity are not lawyers. This means that some services or protections (like attorney-client privilege), may or may not be different from those you could get from a traditional law firm. If you have questions, please contact us at 801.935.2012.